"You are officially a bad son. I give up."
I sent this message to my 24 year old son on Facebook after trying repeatedly to get his help with something and never getting an answer.
I was joking, being offhandedly "ironic" in the same way my mother-in-law threatens to "cut you out of the will" if you cross her. My other kids would have laughed it off, but my son exploded. He messaged me back furiously when he read it the next morning -- a long series of increasingly angry outbursts. He thought I meant it, and his reaction was volcanic. It spurted out of him like blood he was coughing up.
He was the child I was closest to.
It stopped me in my tracks. It was like a blow to the head and the heart at once. The worst of it was, it sounded as final as a door slamming shut so hard it shattered.
In my usual way, I freaked out, went to my crazy place and stumbled outside, where it was 13 degrees with snow on the ground, in my slippers and flimsy sweater. Then I paced the neighborhood sobbing and talking to myself. I couldn't think even one thought straight.
I finally calmed down (after crying for two solid days) - and read his messages again. They were full of rage, but anguish too. He not only took what I said literally, but did so right off the bat. That was the part that knocked me flat: he wasn't sure I loved him.
And now it seemed that I'd missed my chance to prove it to him -- that acute love that started the moment he came out of me, 10 lbs strong and bawling, and never faltered. It sounded like he'd washed his hands of me and walked away for good.
"You can't unsay it," he wrote.
I despaired.
But he called the next night. What? We weren't estranged? I was terrified. What if I said another careless thing? Could I handle his anger? I don't do anger well. But I answered the phone.
Instead of anger I heard a lot of pain. When I asked him if he had closed the door on me, he said "no" in a small voice, "I never meant that." Then he started crying. I don't remember hearing him cry since he was a baby. He was always watchful and shy, trepidatious of new people, but an incredibly avid learner always moving on to the next level, the harder thing, in a hurry to grow up. But now he was crying the way men do, as if they can push it back down their throats if they try hard enough, but of course they can't.
"Do you know," he said, "the hardest thing about growing up with you for my mother?"
I braced myself. There must have been many.
From the beginning, he said, he knew that he couldn't show his emotions or they would hurt me. I would fall apart. I would cry. I would get angry. I would act like his feelings were all about me. And he was trapped, he said, in our house. There was nowhere to go to get away from it. So he learned to not feel. He learned how to hold it all in because if he didn't there would be chaos. To make himself safe he had to take control because I had none.
"But it wasn't your fault! I have bipolar! Anything can make me fall apart, you know that! We've talked about this! It wasn't you!" It was my turn to be anguished.
"It's not about that now, Mom; guilt's not the problem," he said, "I've moved on from that. The problem is I got so good at burying my feelings it's become a habit, and I can't break it."
My son couldn't get close to anyone, I was thinking, because I'd failed him a long, long time ago, even though I tried my best not to. But no, wait. This isn't about me now.
"I thought I'd gotten better at it though," he said, still crying, "I thought I was making progress," still in that small sad voice.
But when my offhand message came through, the dam broke. All the rage he'd suppressed for years came flooding back. And when he called today and I tearfully asked if he was walking away from me, it brought back his fear of hurting me, and all the pain I'd caused by making him -- just a child! -- both the reason and the cure for my sadness, anger, sudden joy, and terror of being abandoned.
He couldn't find intimacy because an old and useless habit held him back.
We talked about all this for a while. I tried not to crumble, or yield to the spreading shock I felt at what had happened between us - so suddenly, so sickeningly. I tried to push it all down in my mind and focus on remaining present to him in the conversation, because if I couldn't do that it would mean I was still the same woman we were talking about, the selfish one who couldn't hear her own child cry without thinking how much it hurt her to hear it.
But as I sat there, I began to notice that several years were settling into my bones. I was a much older person than three days ago. Now if I looked in the mirror, I'd see this new version of me as a mother - this ugly one, who psychologically abused her child; this self-deceiving one, who managed to overcome all her best intentions, fervid self-awareness and desperation to do no harm, and still give her son the gift that keeps on giving: mommy issues.
Soon our conversation winded down. He seemed to feel better for talking about it - for finally letting out all those feelings he’d locked away from me, and then from himself. I hoped the insight he'd had into me as mother resolved things enough that he could move past them. Young people have enough future ahead of them that they can put something in the past and it will stay there.
Once I put the phone down, I didn't feel shocked or panicked anymore. I felt sad, and I knew this sadness would be with me for a very long time. But I also felt something new. The past was different now because I saw it more clearly. But I could live with this new version of me, selfish and blind to her own manipulations as she was. I forgave her. She had bipolar disorder, but she did all she could to love her children, keep them safe, and enable them to grow into good and happy people with many joyful memories. And they had.
I still had bipolar disorder - it’s lifelong - but with treatment, distance and self-examination, I was not that needy mother anymore.
All those years that settled into me as I talked to my son were enough to teach me what we all must learn to do if we are to survive. When we hurt those we love, we accept what we've done, ask for forgiveness, make amends, and then forgive ourselves.
The past had just changed forever, and miraculously I survived.